Community Policing: More than a Cliché
By: Leading Blue
We ask a lot of our police officers. Maybe too much. We expect them to be warriors and guardians, therapists and mediators, enforcers and protectors. One moment, they’re expected to break up a violent confrontation; the next, they’re called to de-escalate a family dispute or coax a person in crisis down from a ledge. The scope is staggering, the stakes impossibly high, and the consequences of failure—well, we’ve all seen those play out on the evening news.
And yet, when you step back, when you strip away the heat of the latest viral video and the noise of the 24-hour outrage cycle, a simple truth remains: policing works best when it’s built on trust. And trust doesn’t grow from a patrol car’s tinted window or a station house’s thick walls. It grows from relationships. It grows from knowing the people you serve not just as calls for service, but as neighbors, business owners, and kids riding their bikes down the street.
That’s the heart of community policing. And despite its buzzword status, despite its occasional slide into political cliché, it’s an idea that still matters.
More Than a PR Campaign
When community policing gets reduced to photo ops—officers playing basketball with teens, handing out ice cream on a hot day—it’s easy to dismiss. Nice gestures, yes, but they don’t move the needle if the deeper work isn’t happening. The real deal is about embedding officers in neighborhoods, not just when there’s trouble, but when there isn’t. It’s about creating partnerships that don’t dissolve the moment a crisis fades. It’s about police officers who know the names of the store owners on their beat, who recognize the elderly woman on her daily walk, who understand the rhythms of the streets they patrol.
And it’s not just about making residents feel good. It’s about making policing more effective. Studies have shown that departments using community policing strategies see reductions in crime and improvements in public cooperation. Why? Because when people trust the police, they report crimes. They provide information. They engage, instead of retreating, and we desperately need that engagement.
The Culture Shift That’s Still Missing
The challenge, of course, is that real community policing requires a culture shift. It demands that departments move beyond a reactive model—where officers respond only when trouble flares—and toward a proactive one, where relationships prevent that trouble from starting in the first place. That means rewarding the officers who invest in long-term community ties, not just the ones who rack up arrests. It means training cops not just in firearms and tactics, but in listening and mediation.
Prior to entering law enforcement, I participated in an internship program with a police department I respected immensely. For the most part, my expectations were met or exceeded, but there was one incident I still haven’t forgotten. I was sitting in a shift briefing as they were getting ready for an afternoon tour. The sergeant finished his remarks, and one of the officers stood up saying, “Time to go f@#k with the public.”
I was floored. I couldn’t believe that a then-modern day law enforcement officer would think this way. Looking back through the lens of a retired law enforcement professional who truly embraced community policing – and as an educator of leadership – I have a second reaction: Where was the supervisor? His failure to get involved is indicative of a deteriorating unit culture. And if there is one thing we’ve learned over the decades is that unit culture matters as much as organizational culture.
True believers must continue to beat the community policing drum. Otherwise, it will be too easy for skeptics and those who prefer a more heavy-handed approach to dismiss it as a tired, dated concept of another time. Our leaders must present it not as a choice but as a way of doing business, the way of doing business. It must be a non-negotiable strategy demanded of every sworn member of the organization. To accept anything less would be a betrayal of those we serve. As the title of this article (Community Policing: More than a Cliché) says, we are most successful if we can convince our people to embrace it.
The question isn’t whether community policing works. It does. The question is whether we have the patience, the discipline, and the political will to make it more than a talking point for promotional interviews and elections. Because trust takes years to build, but only moments to break.
And if we keep getting this wrong, the cost won’t just be measured in crime rates or arrest statistics. It’ll be measured in something much harder to quantify—communities that could have been stronger, safer, and more connected, but weren’t.
That’s a loss we can’t afford.
Back to Law Enforcement Leadership Articles
Andrew A. DeMuth Jr. is the founder of Leading Blue, a firm that provides leadership training for law enforcement and the private sector. He served more than three decades in law enforcement with four different agencies in a variety of leadership roles. During his career, he served as an investigations commander, range master, agency training officer, press information officer, and director of the youth police academy program. He spent the last nine years of his law enforcement career managing CODIS, the New Jersey DNA program overseeing the processing, compliance, and training of more than 500 participating law enforcement agencies and correctional facilities. Today he serves as an adjunct professor for two institutions and speaks on leadership and training topics throughout the country and is the author of A Highly Effective Training Technique Few Are Utilizing.
Additional Reading